Presbyterian
Advance | September 28,
1933 | By Jesse Halsey
Some day some
wise publisher is going to arrange a hums book my way. It will make money for
him and be conducive of orderly worship. (Most worship in non-liturgical churches
is almost fussy.)
These ideas have
been negatived (in practice) by so capable an editor as Augustine Smith and
turned down (to use the vernacular) by several publishers including The Century
Company. But I still maintain that I am right.
There is no need
for improvements. Be honest. Did you ever attend a service in either Sunday
school or church where there was not difficulty in identifying the Responsive
Reading?; where the leader did not find it necessary to say something like
this—“Selection number Seven on Page Eight of The Psalter which is found in the
back of the book, on page five hundred sixty, numbered at the bottom of the
page . . . page 560 selection VII in the back of the Hymnal.” (etc., etc., ad
infinitum . . . ad nauseum.)
How much better
if every unit of worship had an individual number printed in bold type in the
upper left-hand corner (as is done with hymns). First would come the hymns
numbered (say) from 1 to 500 consecutively. Next would come musical Responses
and Chants each numbered (say (501-550. Then would follow the Psalter 551-599
(or whatever the numbers might be). The point is this: From start to finish the
book would be a unity. Each several unity would have a definite designation
easily announced and easily found.
With all its
very excellent qualities The (new Presbyterian) Hymnal fails in this regard.
There are hymns consecutively numbered from 1-513. Then there comes a section
of Responses and Ancient Hymns and Canticles” numbered consecutively 1-95. Then
follows another unit, The Psalter “Selection 1—Selection 75.” Three distinct
units!
In my hymn book
each unit of worship will be carried on one page whether the page is completely
covered or not. The only exception to this rule will be in case of short hymns
where two (or more) can be printed on a page, then each hymn will have a
separate and distinct number in the same conspicuous black face type.
(At the bottom
of each page, inconspicuously printed, will be noted the page number, but this
only for printer’s reference.)
One short
explicit direction will identify, to the worshipper, the item in the leader’s
mind and in the minimum of time said worshipper will turn with assurance to the
correct page and be ready to participate in the worship. Announcing a
responsive reading or chant will be as simple and sure as giving out a hymn.
Why hasn’t some printer done it long ago?
And my Psalter
(using the Authorized Version, which is unsurpassed for liturgical purposes)
will have the response printed in boldface type so that the worshipper may
participate with tease and enthusiasm; and without eye strain, or doubt as to
which lines he is to read.
These changes of
form are not of minor importance. The Psalter in “Common Worship” so well
selected by Dr. Erdman I would have reset so that minister and congregation can
read with ease. Or if that is impossible I will use the responsive readings of
the new Methodist Hymnal which have a short line that the eye can easily
follow.
The hymns I am
not competent to edit, and I shall take over The (New) Hymnal with all of Dr.
Clarence Dickinson’s painstaking and hidden care—if the board and Dr. Laufer
will let me.
–Cincinnati Ohio
No comments:
Post a Comment